For your convenience, all Reader’s Forum submissions are separated by the ## symbol.
In response to Feature Writer Lynne Tatum – Sounds Good to Me and Feature Writer Alena Roberts – Will Braille Ever Be Affordable?, Terri wrote:
Like you, Lynne, I hear beautiful birdsongs early in the morning which seem to say, “Welcome to another new day.”
As the day progresses, I am also bombarded with the undulating beats of Rap and Hip-Hop.
Finally, living in Pennsylvania’s second largest city, I also hear the whoosh of bus and truck airbrakes, horns honking impatiently, and the strident tones of frustrated mothers telling their overly energetic children to “Get over here!”
My final comment is about Alena Roberts’ article in which she wonders if the cost of Braille will ever come down.
As an avid Braille reader and a Library of Congress certified Braille proofreader, I couldn’t agree more with you, Alena, especially given the low rate of Braille Literacy and the high rate of unemployment among America’s blind and visually impaired citizens.
Though I don’t know if the cost of Braille will ever come down as I’d like it to, I’d like to recommend two funding resources in the meantime.
In Pennsylvania, consumers can obtain low-interest loans from the Pennsylvania Initiative on Assistive Technology (PIAT). For more information on this Temple University-based program, call 1-800-204-7428 (1-800-204-PIAT), or contact your area’s Center for Independent Living (CIL). In Pittsburgh, the number for the Three Rivers Center for Independent Living (TRCIL) is 412-371-7700.
The National Federation of the Blind is another excellent source of low-interest loans which can be used for any type of independence-enhancing assistive technology. To learn more about this loan, for which no credit check is conducted, phone 410-659-9314, x2213.
I hope that the above information helps.
##
In response to Feature Writer Alena Roberts – Will Braille Ever Be Affordable?, Gonz Blinko wrote:
As is often the case, I find myself wading into a subject which Freedom Scientific, my former employer, hates to hear discussed. In fact, FS people will deny the veracity of my statements regarding reducing the cost of braille hardware but, if they pipe up, please ask them to offer an alternative explanation that includes facts rather than hearsay.
At CSUN 2001 in San Diego this past March, a friend of mine asked a Freedom Scientific salesperson exactly why braille hardware costs so much. The answer, as one could have predicted, suggested that braille hardware requires braille cells which cost roughly $35 per character. This answer is partially true, most braille devices on the market today use a separate part for each cell on the display and these parts are really very expensive. The incorrect portion, though, is Freedom Scientific’s favorite lie by omission: they do not use these high priced cells but, rather, FS braille devices are made using a single “braille stick” of either 20 or 40 cells.
As one might expect, a single part with 20 or 40 cells is profoundly less expensive than 20 or 40 individual parts. If I remember correctly, when I left FS nearly seven years ago, a 20 cell braille stick cost only a few hundred dollars to manufacture and the 40 cell part cost only a little more. The FS braille stick technology is covered by US and EU patents. The hardware is manufactured in China and the rest of the displays (very cheap housing and very cheap electronics) are also built in China where they are assembled, boxed, and shipped to distribution points around the world.
So, one way to lower the price of braille devices would be by using technology similar to that which FS has in place. With the current state of the braille hardware biz, only FS seems to have dramatically lowered the cost of building such devices, so without any real price competition, FS can enjoy windfall profits on their sales.
For the past fifteen years or so, since I started following access technology closely, there have also been several research projects that seemed promising but have never made it to market. Some of these new ideas failed for lack of funding but most failed because they simply did not work. These notions included everything from smart metal alloys to an air pressure based system which showed some promise in the lab but failed badly when researchers tried to expand them to a usable system. This is how research works, many failures take time and money in the hopes that a single major discovery will advance the art with something really innovative.
##
In response to Feature Writer Alena Roberts – Will Braille Ever Be Affordable?, Chantelle wrote:
Now that is something we also ponder about here in South-Africa.
Almost everything we blind people use is imported from America. Most of us have to borrow money to buy the things we need. Most of the technology costs more than the blind pension that we get. So if I would have liked a braille display or even jaws, I would have to go without food for a few years in order to buy it. Even something like a talking or braille watches are getting really expensive for us. Even worse, we have to really look after our things that we were able to afford. I had a braille/talking watch which only worked for a year after it was modified by a shop and then broke again by that very same shop after sending it for a new battery. Now I have to save up for a new one all over again. Most of the technology that I do know of that blind people use around here doesn’t even belong to them. It belongs to the place where they work. Some are really lucky to have such things at home because it was sponsored to them. So yes, I would also like to know why technology for the blind costs as much as a car or house. Why make things like that if the blind can’t even afford it? Don’t the people do research before they make these things?
##
In response to Feature Writer Alena Roberts – Will Braille Ever Be Affordable?, Allison wrote:
I don’t understand the technology that goes in to braille displays either, so I don’t know how it could be made more affordable, but I share Alena’s fear that braille could become a thing of the past if prices don’t come down. I am writing this from my braillenote Apex that I was able to convince the state to purchase for me as a college student. I absolutely love it, but when it goes on the fritz, I don’t know that I will be able to convince the state to replace it. This note taker has been crucial to my college success as it is much more portable and efficient for me than laptop computers are. But when I enter the workforce, I will most likely spend the whole day in one office where it will be a lot more practical to do my job on a computer equipped with JAWS. Given the budget cuts everywhere these days, I doubt I could convince the state to purchase a braillenote merely for pleasure reading when I get off work. Even if I find a job that pays well, I am sure it will be hard to justify spending thousands of dollars on braille technology given the cost of living (I might end up biting the bullet and buying one anyway because I love it so much, but would prefer the price to come down first). Thank you, Alena, for bringing attention to this issue.
##
Beth wrote in, saying:
Re: Negative attitudes
I was disheartened about all the negativity presented in the July 11, 2011 “Readers’ Forum” and I will make general statements, as this letter would be too long if I specifically addressed each issue in detail. If a sighted person’s attitude or desired action concerning you or the blind in general bothers you, chalk it up to ignorance, misinformation, or a desire to help–rarely does harmful intent come into play. Remember that you are not perfect, so use tact and kindness in response to people always. This is the only right response to such situations. You can be polite and firm, exemplifying confidence. Never let anyone else’s attitude change yours regarding a topic under discussion with anyone, unless you see that yours needs changing, then thank the person for stating the new idea. If you do not agree but the other person persists, just say the idea is something you will consider and politely drop the conversation. Regarding the expense associated with Braille technology, a sighted driver will pay big bucks for a Rolls-Royce. Since this product is in a niche market, it’s no different with note takers and Braille displays.
##
In response to Op Ed with Bob Branco – Ignorance of Our Abilities, Rev. George Gray wrote:
I read with interest and amusement Bob Branco’s article, “Ignorance of Our Abilities” in the July 11 Ziegler Magazine. Let me tell you my story.
Originally, I trained as a teacher at Buffalo State College in Buffalo, NY. I graduated with a 3.5 average on a 4.0 scale in 1970. I then went on for my MS degree in education because of a 100% paid scholarship–not related to Voc. Rehab who did pay, thankfully, for my undergraduate degree. I finished that MS with a 3.3 grade point average out of 4.
I said the above to illustrate that I am not a dunce. In my life I have been able to figure out things. I completed student teaching and the biggest problem for me was finding a ride to and from the school where I taught, but I accomplished that too.
As I was approaching graduation, I needed and wanted a job. I remember one interview with an assistant superintendent of a local school system. I dressed conservatively and went in for the job interview. After meeting the gentleman, he said that a lady teacher in the school system would be conducting the interview and then he dismissed himself and left the room. I thought this strange since I knew he had conducted other interviews–so why not talk to me? I don’t bite–growl maybe–but not bite.
When he left I decided that I would take charge of the situation. I figured that she did not have the authority or power to hire anyway. Why did he leave? What do I have to lose? Did I make him that uncomfortable? Did I forget my deodorant….hmmm! I thought and still maintain his actions were totally rude and very unprofessional. Well she asked me a question–frankly I can’t remember what it was. I answered it and then asked her how long she had taught; where she went to school; was she married; tell me about your family; why did you choose teaching as a career and on and on. Inside I was upset over this whole thing. I figured the entire interview was useless, so why not have some fun.
About 30 minutes later the assistant superintendent returned and as he entered, he casually said, “Well how are things going in here?” I stated, “Well I’ve learned a lot about your teacher–I also know that your school system doesn’t meet my standards for professionalism and I am not interested in continuing talks further.” I then got up and left.
All my interviews were not like this though, thank heavens. I remember another interview where I was asked a question about teaching geography to fifth graders. It was, I believed, a legitimate question. They asked, “If you sent a student to the U. S. map in the front of the room and asked them to point out say West Virginia, how would you know they did it?” I said, “Before I answer you…and I will, let me say that you are asking this question from the perspective of a sighted person. You have seen all your life. This is what you know. You are familiar with answers based on what you see. Now I, being blind, have to figure out a solution to solve the same problem. Bear in mind I have considered situations like this for many years and have come up with alternatives, so I would ask the student…what is to the north of West Virginia; what is to the south of West Virginia; to the east and to the west? By the student’s answers I know whether or not they have pointed out West Virginia”
The interviewer must have liked my answer and my introspection into other areas of teaching because I ended up getting the job.
Landing my first teaching job, however, was not an easy task. I estimate that I filled out probably 150 applications and went to probably 100 interviews all over the country. I remember hitchhiking with my guide dog to make it to a job interview because I missed the bus. It takes persistence and yes you do get discouraged, but a job at the end makes it all worthwhile!
##
In response to Feature Writer Alena Roberts – Prayer Will Not Cure My Blindness, Elaine wrote:
I am a Christian and I’ve been to a few churches and Bible studies where people have made unkind remarks about my blindness. I’ve had people tell me that I’m not ready to see and if I had enough faith I’d be able to see. I’ve been totally blind all my life and someone told me that the devil got into either me, my mother, or the doctor when I was born. I think some Christians take what they have for granted. They act like they’ve earned their sight and all their other faculties because they have a proper relationship with God. Nothing could be further from the truth. There are people who don’t believe in God who have all their faculties. It’s a shame that some people can be so cruel and insensitive. My blindness has nothing to do with my relationship with God. I was blind before I knew anything about anything. Jesus didn’t condemn people who had disabilities–he simply healed them. When Jesus was asked by his disciples whose sin caused a man who was blind from birth to be blind, he said that no one’s sin caused his blindness. Some Christians need to appreciate what they have and not be so quick to judge people who are different than they are.