To navigate between reader’s forum posts, please search for the ## symbol by using your browser or word processor’s search or find function.
Recently, the Matilda Ziegler Magazine featured an article by Alena Roberts, celebrating the 20th anniversary of the Americans with Disabilities Act, and MS Roberts’ opinion as to how she had personally benefitted from the ADA. Since Ms. Roberts states that she was a child when the ADA was passed, perhaps she does not know of the successes of those of us who came before.
Ms. Roberts almost implies that a blind person would not have been successful in obtaining a college education before the passage of the ADA. I, and many others, did successfully complete college before this time, and, though some of the things which the ADA helped her obtain may have been good, I do not see her “list of accommodations” as an unmitigated positive thing.
Extra time for tests: I see no reason why a blind person should have extra time for tests. As I typed my exam essays, and my classmates wrote them by hand, I probably could put things on paper much faster than my sighted colleagues. I didn’t need extra time.
Note takers: I think the concept of providing a blind person with a note taker is one of the worst ideas that has ever come out of the so-called “disability services” which now flourish on college campuses. I used to take my cassette recorder to class, record the relevant part of the lecture, then go to my room and take Braille notes while the class was fresh in my mind. With the existence of the many very quiet note taking devices available to us, why can’t a blind student take his/her own notes! Anyway, I would not want to take notes for another person, I would not want another person to take notes for me, only I could know what I want to write down, and what I didn’t need to record.
I don’t like the concept of “list of accommodations.” It sounds very much like, “You had better help me, or else!” When I attended college, and graduate school, I made my own arrangements by talking directly to the professor. All professors were extremely helpful to me, and I didn’t need some office or agency on campus to intervene and do my negotiating. This was the first time I had to work out for myself arrangements between a sighted person in authority; ie: the professor, and me. It was very, very good training for later life.
If not on college campus, then where does a young blind person learn to cope with, and move through the sighted world? I think the ADA does things we blind students can and should do for ourselves.
Tim Hendel
Huntsville, Alabama
##
In response to Op Ed with Bob Branco – What Will Happen to Consumer Groups? (August 16, 2010)
I think I have to disagree somewhat. My brother and I first heard about the NFB and the ACB back in the summer of 1994, when our dad took us to part of the NFB convention when they were here in Chicago. We went to the exhibit hall, and that’s where we purchased Type n’ Speaks. We also attended part of the day’s general session, which was led by Marc Maurer. If memory serves me correct, we were taken aback by some things he said but I can’t remember exactly what they were. If my brother is reading this, he can feel free to correct me if I’m wrong. What I do remember, though, is that he and I were booted off one of the NFB’s email discussion lists for good just because we disagreed with them on the subject of audio description. I’m pretty sure we weren’t even given a fair warning either. Or if we were, it was done in a very harsh and unacceptable manner. Anyway, I began receiving publications in Braille from both organizations. I found myself agreeing more with the American Council of the Blind. They just seemed to have an open-door policy, where basically anything was accepted even if it was an opposing viewpoint. Most, if not all, of the literature from the NFB just didn’t sound right at all to me.
Jump ahead a few years, when I read that “People of Vision: A History of the American Council of the Blind” was available. So I ordered it on cassette from my local talking book center. These two organizations used to be one, until some pretty major turmoil occurred. They split in the summer of 1961 at the convention. While it is certainly true that the NFB has accomplished some good things, I strongly disagree with their approach on many levels. It seems to me that a whole lot more good could and would be accomplished if these organizations would reunite.
I don’t want to sound like a whiner and complainer, but why don’t the NFB and ACB just reunite? I think other disability organizations have done more today for our cause. Even in the deaf community, some of whom oppose cochlear implants have done a lot of good things.
Jake
##
In response to Feature Writer Steven Famiglietti – Overview of LEEP 2010 (August 16, 2010)
It sounds like the students had a terrific week. I would hope that, in the future, students would meet representatives from both the National Federation of the Blind and the American Council of the Blind. People should be exposed to the philosophies of both organizations so that they can make educated choices about whether they wish to become involved in the consumer movement and which organization suits their beliefs and advocacy style.
I’m glad to learn of the experiences of the students and I know that they will look back at the week with many fond memories.
Don
##
In response to Tech Corner with Steven Famiglietti (August 23, 2010)
I just read your tech section and you might put into future issues of the magazine about the new Samsung Haven cell phone. I have one; it comes with speech, and is available through Verizon. It speaks everything, is perfect for the blind, and only cost me $43 with the signing of a contract. It even does the sub menus.
Lynn Rosenberg
##
In response to Feature Writer Alena Roberts – The Ups and Downs of Self-Employment (August 23, 2010)
I very much enjoyed reading this. I am this close to just throwing in the towel with regards to employment, but everyone wants me to pursue it so I guess I may somehow. I am just freaked out by the thought of going through vocational rehabilitation, due in part to my state being ranked dead worst concerning services for people with disabilities. I have two nonprofit jobs which I love, and I previously worked at a nonprofit which is more or less defunct. I love all this assistive technology, so perhaps I’ll someday be able to start my own tech business. Who knows? Anyway, this is great information.
Jake