For your convenience, all Reader’s Forum submissions are separated by the ## symbol.
In response to Feature Writer Lynne Tatum – Learning Braille–A Touching Process, and Feature Writer Alena Roberts – The Quest to Create a Low Cost Braille Display, Tim wrote:
I read with interest Lynne Tatum’s article about learning Braille as an adult, and Alena Roberts’ article about the cost of producing Braille material and Braille displays. I will comment on both articles.
Congratulations, Lynne, for the effort you are putting into this! It will pay off later! Though I learned Braille in Kindergarten, at the New York State School for the Blind, and use it every day, myself, I taught Braille to adults for many years. During my work and travels, I used English, Spanish, and Afrikaans in my teaching. One interesting thing I found was that, for people who speak a second language, no matter how well they spoke it, it was always best to start them off in their native language. The intuition which helps you guess and understand what you are reading works much better in your first language.
As stated, I use Braille every day. Yet I do not borrow books from the NLS libraries. This may mean that, according to the statistics, I am not a Braille reader, even though I use slate and stylus, Perkins brailler, and I used to have a Braille printer for my computer.
Is it only the cost of Braille books and Braille equipment that causes the numbers of children learning Braille to be so low? I strongly say that this is not the only reason. In our current main-streaming educational system, I believe that there is a definite bias against Braille on the part of teachers who teach our blind and visually impaired children. Most of these teachers are sighted, their knowledge of Braille is weak, at best, and they just don’t want to be bothered, or those funding this education don’t think Braille is valuable. Ask these same teachers if we should eliminate hand writing instruction for their sighted children. Imagine the loud choruses of “no way!” that you would get. Ask any adult blind person who is a fluent Braille reader, no matter how often or rarely that person uses Braille, and he/she will be more than likely to say, “I wouldn’t give up my Braille knowledge for the world.”
I strongly and assertively promote Braille whenever I am asked about it.
Tim Hendel
Huntsville, Alabama
##
In response to Feature Writer Lynne Tatum – Learning Braille–A Touching Process, Duane wrote:
Braille is an awesome medium of communication that must never disappear! I was delighted to read Lynne Tatum’s article about learning Braille. As both pastor and musician, I have read Braille all my life. Louis Braille’s birthday should be commemorated annually everywhere. Keep up the good work of learning, whoever you are, and wherever you are!
##
In response to Feature Writer Lynne Tatum – Learning Braille–A Touching Process, Andrew wrote:
I am teaching myself Braille using flash cards and a deck of Braille playing cards. I find that in today’s cyber society it is hard to find motivation when you can have smart phones, screen readers, and books on tape.
##
In response to Feature Writer Lynne Tatum – Learning Braille–A Touching Process, Andrew wrote:
It is encouraging in this age of declining Braille literacy to read about someone going back to reading Braille. As a lifelong Braille reader, I agree that it is a very peaceful way to read, but I still remember how frustrating it was to learn even as a child. I especially remember how I used to get e and i mixed up and how my teacher, who was also fun, would pretend I hurt the feelings of letter e when I called it an i! I also had tracking problems for quite a few years, but the good news is, if you are going to work mostly with Braille notetakers, the Braille display only shows one line at a time, so that might make tracking easier for you. Good luck!
##
In response to Karen Crowder – Will 2012 Bring in a New Age of Civility and Politeness? Danni wrote:
I went through this a couple years ago when I was dropped off at Target rather than Toys R Us where I was supposed to be going! Turned out scheduler messed up, but anyway, I figured I’m here I’ll do some shopping since by the time paratransit could get back to get me it would be too late to shop elsewhere and got a shocking response from the manager: “We don’t offer a service like that.” Oh well, okay I got back on the phone and called paratransit back and told them to please find a driver to take me home, they don’t want my money at Target! I have spread the word much since!
Walmart, though, at times has been interesting help. But they have always been willing to help!
##
In response to Karen Crowder – Will 2012 Bring in a New Age of Civility and Politeness? David wrote:
Hello,
I dread shopping alone, not because I can’t do it, I have and will again. I dread it because I never know who I’ll end up getting to help me. Will they be in a hurry and sort of rush me along? Will they get me what they think I have asked for, but maybe it’s the Vanilla Coke not the Cherry Coke or the chunky peanut butter, not the natural smooth? Will my groceries be bagged such that my bread is smashed? Will the para-transit driver help me load or just sit in the van near where I am standing with my basket, motor running, and not roll the window down to let me know it’s my ride, not who knows who out there? Will I have too many bags for the para-transit driver not to tell me not to have more than 3? Will I miss new and interesting items because the shopper helper has no idea what I might like to try?
As to the couple at the mall, I think the security was rude. But I think that if you are going at a very busy time, you take a chance they are busy. I always try to avoid extremely busy times at malls where I rarely go anyway–overpriced often and the noise from echoes and inside fountains makes a sound-fog that gives me a headache. I don’t expect people to be helpful anymore. It seems everyone is in a hurry, expects technology to help us, or people just think we should be more independent or they get tired of helping when you don’t ever improve. I sometimes think the advances in technology will continue to make an ever-more independent group of blind people but the group risks becoming smaller and smaller unless older blind people can keep up with the technology changes and afford the new things. There are so many things out now, iPads, iPhones, iTouches, iMacks, Windows 7, several notetakers, Victor Streams, NLS downloadable books, NFB Newsline items, Audio.com books, Bookshare.org and Learningally.org items, commercial audio, and other resources. I feel a bit lost at times and definitely old now.